【时代杂志20131204】中国欺骗世界学生排名系统PISA

已注册会员

China is Cheating the World Student Rankings System
中国欺骗世界学生排名系统
Enough is enough: Beijing must supply national data to assessors and not simply the results of a small minority of elite students
够了！北京必须提供国家数据来评审，而不是简单的少数优秀学生的成绩。

网友吐槽：

美国人最大的问题：自己是最好的，问题都是别人造成的。由此可见一斑。不去检讨为
什么自己连越南都不如，而去说中国cheat.中国哪里有cheat？排名上面明明写着
Shanghai-China,而不是China.自己愿意怎么解读是自己的事情，怎么能怪别人？就算
是上海，人口已经超过了麻省和康州的综合，而人均收入却远不如这两个州。为什么
2300万人口的上海还是远远超过这两个美国最好的成绩？美国人为什么不去这么想？

相反，这事情若是放在中国。定有一帮自恨的公知跳出来喊“我拿什么来战胜这样的民
族？”美国人的自我感觉良好注定了美国走下坡路。而大多自恨的中国人却有缺少美国
人的这种心态。

bobsm 15 minutes ago
so the Americans cheated too.

" School systems in Connecticut, Florida and Massachusetts were among the only three states to represent the U.S. in the 2012 PISA study."

wuqijun 1 hour ago
David Stout:  you are a bigot and a China hater.  Stop bashing China!

posthuman1 1 hour ago
@wuqijun you might be correct. but please prove it. it does not make much sense just "argue" like this.

andycorson 1 hour ago
@posthuman1 @wuqijun My question is simply whether or not you have worked in the China education system? I don't have definitive information for either side of this topic, but I do work in China and in education and I can say what ruby33136 is very much in line with what I have observed. So what have you observed?

posthuman1 13 minutes ago
@andycorson I do have some, if not extensive working experiences in higher education in both countries, but not in K-12. Of course ruby33136 is correct.